Connect with us

World News

‘A home for trees and birds, and also humans’: How high-rise forests can transform city life – and make us happier

Published

on

It’s been 10 years since the creation of the first vertical forest, Milan’s Bosco Verticale. How has it inspired other buildings – and affected their residents’ happiness and health?

In 2007, Italian architect Stefano Boeri witnessed the frantic construction of a city in the Dubai desert dominated by energy-wasting skyscrapers covered in glass, ceramic and metal. All these materials, he tells the BBC, “reflected sunlight, generating heat in the air and especially on the urban ground, where pedestrians walked”. Three thousand miles away, he had just begun working on his own design for two very tall buildings in a neglected area of northern Milan. “Suddenly, it occurred to me to create two biological towers… covered not with glass, but with leaves,” he says. The design would invite fauna and flora into this industrial wasteland and cool the air inside and out, offering a radical new architectural prototype that, he explains, “integrates living nature as a constitutive part of it”. The startling result was the world’s first “vertical forest”.

Boeri Studio/ Dimitar Harizanov Milan's Bosco Verticale – completed 10 years ago – was the world's first vertical forest (Credit: Boeri Studio/ Dimitar Harizanov)
Milan’s Bosco Verticale – completed 10 years ago – was the world’s first vertical forest (Credit: Boeri Studio/ Dimitar Harizanov)

The multi-award-winning design is now 10 years old, its plants maintained by “flying gardeners” harnessed to the side of the buildings, and its occupants up to three degrees cooler, as the foliage releases water vapour and filters the sunlight. To mark this anniversary, architectural firm Stefano Boeri Architetti has released a new book, Bosco Verticale: Morphology of a Vertical Forest, featuring essays by leading voices working at the intersection of nature and architecture, alongside images by architectural photographer Iwan Baan. The book traces the evolution of the project and the principles it espouses, and, say the publishers, Rizzoli “celebrates an architectural work that has become the symbol of a renewed collective sensibility toward care for the environment and the plant world”.

Since the completion of Milan’s Vertical Forest, a green wave of plant-rich construction has begun reintroducing nature into our cities

In a reversal of the usual architectural hierarchies, the book describes the vertical forest as “a home for trees and birds, that also houses humans”. It draws on philosophies and texts that have influenced it, such as The Secret Life of Trees (2006) by British biologist Colin Tudge, a work that explains the crucial role trees play in our lives in sequestering carbon, producing glucose and providing shade. It also quotes the British ethologist Dame Jane Goodall. As populations increase, she asserts, “it is desperately important that this growth should be accompanied by new incentives to bring the natural world into existing cities and into the planning of new ones”.

Stefano Boeri Architetti Nanjing Vertical Forest in China follows the principles of Bosco Verticale (Credit: Stefano Boeri Architetti)
Nanjing Vertical Forest in China follows the principles of Bosco Verticale (Credit: Stefano Boeri Architetti)

Since the completion of Milan’s Vertical Forest, a green wave of plant-rich construction has begun reintroducing nature into our cities, from Dubai to Denver, Colorado; Antwerp to Arlington, Virginia; with Africa’s first vertical forest scheduled to break ground in Cairo later this year. Answering critics who doubted the concept’s affordability is the Trudo Vertical Forest in Eindhoven, The Netherlands (completed 2021), a social housing project with a rent cap of €600 (£510) per month.

A sense of connection

Over in Montpellier, France, a third of The Secret Gardens − a forested residential development designed by Vincent Callebaut Architectures, Paris, and due for completion later this year − will be reserved for affordable housing. In integrating practices such as rooftop agriculture and water recycling, The Secret Gardens also “addresses the climate crisis by restoring the human-nature connection”, Vincent Callebaut tells the BBC. “By transforming residents into urban gardeners and façades into carbon sinks, this building demonstrates that ecology isn’t a constraint but a lifestyle philosophy,” he says.

BES Engineering The 21-storey-high Tao Zhu Yin Yuan in Taipei, Taiwan, was completed in 2024 (Credit: BES Engineering)
The 21-storey-high Tao Zhu Yin Yuan in Taipei, Taiwan, was completed in 2024 (Credit: BES Engineering)

The power of these extraordinary structures to alter how people live and feel is central to their design. One of Vincent Callebaut Architectures’ latest designs is The Rainbow Tree (Cebu, Philippines), inspired by the psychedelic colours of the native Rainbow Eucalyptus Tree‘s bark. But the “tree” requires the collaboration of the residents of each of its 300 apartments to maintain its striking flora. This, along with its shared greenhouses and urban beehives, helps “foster social bonds”, says Callebaut, creating a sense of community and connection.

More like this:

• The retro space-age homes that still inspire today

• Why these 1970s cabins are ‘the perfect holiday home’

• The pioneering building that scandalised Paris

This notion that biophilic design (design that draws on humans’ innate connection with nature) can positively affect our wellbeing is supported by recent research. A study undertaken by Wageningen University in the Netherlands reported that the presence of plants in a work environment not only improved the attractiveness of the workspace, but also increased employee satisfaction. Workers also noticed the enhanced air quality and reported fewer health-related complaints.

Nature is not something that exists in an immemorial past – it is and will always be our technological future – Emanual Coccia

In Wales, a 10-year study looking at the presence of anxiety and depression in 2.3 million medical records, found that the greenest home surroundings were associated with 40% less anxiety and depression than those living in the least green areas. People in poorer areas benefitted the most, with access to green spaces and water reducing the risk of anxiety and depression by 10% (6% in wealthier areas).

BES Engineering Tao Zhu Yin Yuan features rotating balconies that optimise sunlight (Credit: BES Engineering)
Tao Zhu Yin Yuan features rotating balconies that optimise sunlight (Credit: BES Engineering)

It is perhaps unsurprising, then, that biophilic concepts are being commissioned for new hospitals. Callebaut’s Hospiwood 21, in La Louvière, Belgium, says the architect, “incorporates therapeutic vertical forests using greenery to reduce patient stress and enhance recovery”, and is furnished with a soothing biophilic interior full of cascading plants. Meanwhile, in Italy, Stefano Boeri’s New Policlinico Hospital Milan will feature a rooftop garden of more than 7,000 square metres. Biophilia is part of a rethinking of care facilities, says Boeri, that “opens up a new perspective on rehabilitation, going beyond the traditional concept of a facility for the mere long-term care of patients and becoming a true space of interaction and wellbeing in close contact with nature”.

In fact, the green tendrils of biophilic design are creeping into a huge range of buildings. Jewel Changi Airport, Singapore’s 10-storey leisure and retail complex, has been open to both air passengers and visitors since 2019, and boasts lush indoor forests comprising 1,400 trees, as well as the world’s tallest indoor waterfall (40m). In Amsterdam, the sustainable bamboo interior of the Hotel Jakarta (founded 2018) features a tropical garden in its central atrium that, quenched by rainwater from the roof, is fast advancing towards its 30-metre high ceiling. An hour away in Rotterdam, a rooftop forest, almost 40m above ground level, crowns The Depot, a publicly accessible storage facility for the vast art collection of the Museum Boijmans van Beuningen, and shaped like a giant mirrored cauldron.

As well as lifting our spirits, high-rise forests can play an important role in tackling climate change. Vincent Callebaut’s Tao Zhu Yin Yuan in Taipei, Taiwan, a 21-floor tower that is shaped like DNA’s double helix, was completed in 2024. Its 23,000 plants absorb an estimated 130 tons of CO2 each year, and their cooling effect on the façade reduces the need for air conditioning by 30%. The building features rotating balconies to maximise sun exposure, while the ventilation chimneys at its core reflects Callebaut’s interest in biomimicry (the emulation of nature’s systems to provide solutions to human problems) and function much like a lung, drawing in air at its base, purifying it, and then expelling it at the top.

Boeri Studio/ Giovanni Nardi The multi-award-winning Bosco Verticale keeps its inhabitants cool, and provides a home for birds as well as humans (Credit: Boeri Studio/ Giovanni Nardi)
The multi-award-winning Bosco Verticale keeps its inhabitants cool, and provides a home for birds as well as humans (Credit: Boeri Studio/ Giovanni Nardi)

Far taller than they are wide, high-rise forests also minimise soil sealing, freeing up land for nature and reducing flood risk. “My projects embody a vision where cities are no longer climate problems but living solutions,” says Callebaut. Far from nature being “an obstacle or ornamental afterthought”, it’s the guiding principle of the design. Buildings now act, he says, as “inhabited trees… that absorb CO2, produce energy, and shelter biodiversity”. Responding to two major contemporary crises, global warming and declining mental health, biophilic buildings are already being envisaged as part of entirely forested cities. In Liuzhou in China’s Guangxi province, one of the world’s worst regions for smog, Stefano Boeri’s futuristic Forest City, housing around 30,000 inhabitants and generating all of its own energy, has been approved and is awaiting construction; while the firm’s Cancun Smart Forest City in Mexico, which plans to prohibit combustion-powered vehicles, is also awaiting starter’s orders.

Back in Milan, the building that began it all, with its rooftop solar panels, is indisputably tree-like, harvesting its energy from the sun and drawing up groundwater. “Nature is not something that exists in an immemorial past,” writes author and philosopher Emanuele Coccia in the book. “It is and will always be our technological future.” As for Boeri, the twin vertical forests he brought to life in Milan are not just buildings, he writes, but “a political manifesto” with “a simple and popular message: living nature has to return to inhabit the spaces conceived for humans. No more, no less”.

Bosco Verticale: Morphology of a Vertical Forest is edited by Stefano Boeri Architetti and published by Rizzoli.

—   

If you liked this story, sign up for The Essential List newsletter – a handpicked selection of features, videos and can’t-miss news, delivered to your inbox twice a week.

Continue Reading

World News

The Deadly Hypocrisy of Western Sanctions

Published

on

By

Paris (Imran Y. CHOUDHRY) :- Former Press Secretary to the President, Former Press Minister to the Embassy of Pakistan to France, Former MD, SRBC Mr. Qamar Bashir analysis : “Power tends to corrupt, and absolute power corrupts absolutely.” Lord Acton’s enduring maxim finds devastating confirmation in a major study published in The Lancet Global Health, which estimated that unilateral economic sanctions were associated with approximately 38 million excess deaths worldwide between 1971 and 2021. This staggering human toll exposes the contradiction at the heart of the Western-led international order: nations that proclaim themselves guardians of human rights, champions of democracy and defenders of human dignity have employed economic coercion associated with the deaths of millions of innocent people. The self-appointed protectors of humanity have become instruments of extraordinary human suffering.
The contradiction is staggering. Countries that lecture the world on morality, international law and humanitarian responsibility frequently reserve for themselves the privilege of violating those very principles. Their economic dominance becomes an instrument of punishment, their military superiority a license for destruction, and their political influence a shield against accountability. The victims are overwhelmingly ordinary people who have neither declared war nor formulated the policies for which they are punished.
The instruments of coercion are principally two: military aggression and economic strangulation. The first destroys cities, infrastructure, hospitals, schools and livelihoods through bombs and missiles. The second accomplishes comparable devastation more slowly, through financial blockades, trade restrictions, frozen assets, banking prohibitions and the systematic deprivation of essential economic resources.
One kills through explosions; the other through hunger, disease, poverty and the collapse of public services. Both can devastate entire generations.
The cruelty of economic warfare becomes particularly apparent when its architects openly celebrate the suffering it produces. In remarks attributed to US Secretary of State Marco Rubio, the devastating impact of sanctions and economic restrictions on Iran was presented as pressure that compounds with time. The argument was that economic deprivation would eventually undermine the government’s ability to sustain its institutions, compensate its personnel and maintain political control.
Such reasoning exposes the disturbing logic underlying economic strangulation. When workers cannot receive wages, families cannot afford food, hospitals struggle to obtain medicines and inflation destroys purchasing power, civilian suffering becomes an instrument of geopolitical pressure. Human deprivation is no longer treated merely as an unfortunate consequence; it becomes part of the mechanism through which political objectives are pursued.
The scientific evidence behind this indictment is particularly disturbing. The study, titled Effects of international sanctions on age-specific mortality: a cross-national panel data analysis, examined 152 countries over five decades. Its researchers estimated an average annual mortality burden of approximately 564,258 deaths associated with unilateral sanctions in recent years.
These were not primarily battlefield casualties. They represented the consequences of deteriorating economic conditions, restricted access to essential goods, weakened healthcare systems and the broader deprivation associated with sanctions.
Most horrifying was the disproportionate suffering of children. According to the research estimates, children younger than five accounted for approximately 51 percent of sanction-associated deaths. Children and older people together represented an overwhelming proportion of the estimated mortality burden.
These findings expose the enormous distance between the declared objectives of economic sanctions and their actual humanitarian consequences. Measures supposedly directed against political leaders, military organizations and governing elites fall most heavily upon infants, patients, workers, pensioners and families struggling to survive.
The political leadership that sanctions are designed to weaken frequently retains privileged access to resources. Security institutions continue functioning, influential elites exploit alternative commercial networks, and politically connected businesses benefit from scarcity. Meanwhile, independent enterprises collapse, ordinary employees lose their livelihoods, and the middle class gradually disappears.
Economic punishment can therefore strengthen the very structures it claims to dismantle. Governments consolidate control over scarce resources, black markets flourish, and populations become increasingly dependent upon political authorities for survival.
The historical record provides compelling illustrations. Cuba has endured decades of American economic restrictions without the political transformation Washington originally sought. North Korea developed nuclear weapons despite extensive international sanctions. Iran survived successive campaigns of maximum pressure while expanding alternative economic relationships. Venezuela experienced devastating economic hardship without the immediate political collapse anticipated by proponents of sanctions.
Iraq suffered catastrophic economic and humanitarian deterioration during the sanctions imposed throughout the 1990s. Yet Saddam Hussein remained in power until the American-led military invasion of 2003. The civilian population paid an enormous price for policies that failed to achieve their central political objective through economic pressure alone.
Iran now stands at the center of another confrontation between geopolitical ambition and humanitarian consequences. American restrictions on banking, oil exports, financial transactions and international commerce have imposed severe economic difficulties. Currency depreciation, inflation, weakened purchasing power and obstacles to essential imports have placed immense pressure upon ordinary Iranian households.
The people suffering these consequences are not necessarily participants in government decisions. They are teachers, doctors, laborers, students, shopkeepers, children and elderly citizens whose fundamental aspiration is to live with dignity.
The same contradiction extends to Israel’s military conduct across the Middle East. Gaza has suffered immense civilian casualties, widespread displacement and the destruction of essential infrastructure. Israeli settlement expansion and occupation in the West Bank continue to deprive Palestinians of land, security and political rights. Israeli military operations in Lebanon and Syria have further intensified regional instability.
Israel’s military capabilities are sustained substantially by American assistance, weapons supplies and diplomatic protection. Washington’s professed commitment to civilian protection consequently stands in sharp contrast to its continued support for military operations that have produced catastrophic humanitarian consequences.
This is not merely a question of contradictory foreign policy. It concerns the concentration of international power in the hands of governments that claim universal moral authority while resisting equivalent scrutiny of their own conduct.
International human rights cannot remain credible when their application depends upon the identity of the perpetrator. The right to food, healthcare, livelihood and human dignity cannot be defended selectively. Nor can the suffering of children become acceptable because their governments refuse to submit to external political demands.
The most disturbing revelation of the Lancet research is that economic warfare can produce a human toll comparable in magnitude to armed conflict without attracting equivalent international outrage. Its victims die quietly, in hospitals without supplies, homes without adequate food and communities whose economic foundations have been systematically undermined.
A world order that condemns violence while normalizing mass civilian deprivation has surrendered its moral legitimacy. When powerful nations can devastate populations through bombs or blockades and still present themselves as champions of humanity, Lord Acton’s warning becomes more than a historical observation.
Absolute power has not merely corrupted the guardians of human rights; it has enabled them to transform human suffering into an instrument of policy while demanding that the world applaud their moral leadership.

Continue Reading

World News

Europe’s Colonial Ambitions Against Russia

Published

on

By

Paris (Imran Y. CHOUDHRY) :- Former Press Secretary to the President, Former Press Minister to the Embassy of Pakistan to France, Former MD, SRBC Mr. Qamar Bashir analysis : The imperial ambitions that once propelled European powers across continents in pursuit of territory, wealth, natural resources and geopolitical supremacy have returned to haunt their architects. For centuries, Britain and other European powers accumulated enormous fortunes by exploiting weaker nations, extracting their resources and controlling their political destinies. The collapse of the Soviet Union presented Europe with another historic opportunity: to extend its influence eastward, weaken Russia, surround it strategically and ultimately gain leverage over its immense natural wealth. Yet the grand strategy intended to diminish Russia has produced a spectacular reversal. Russia remains standing, while Europe confronts economic difficulties, political instability, public resentment and the consequences of its own strategic miscalculations.
Karl Marx recognized that capitalism possessed an extraordinary capacity to create an interconnected global economy. Markets, industries, trade routes and financial systems would eventually bind distant societies into a single economic structure. What this expansion produced, however, was an international order characterized by staggering inequalities. Western Europe, North America and Japan accumulated extraordinary wealth, while much of Asia, Africa and Latin America endured colonial exploitation, economic dependency and persistent poverty. The global economy became interconnected without becoming equitable. Its prosperity was concentrated among the powerful, while its burdens were disproportionately imposed upon the powerless.
European colonialism was never merely about planting flags or establishing administrative control. Its central objective was economic extraction. Colonized territories supplied raw materials, cheap labor, captive markets and strategic routes through which imperial powers accumulated wealth. Political domination protected economic privilege, while military superiority enforced submission. The vocabulary of imperialism subsequently changed, but the pursuit of resources, markets and geopolitical advantage remained deeply embedded in international power struggles.
The dissolution of the Soviet Union in 1991 fundamentally transformed Europe’s strategic landscape. Russia inherited enormous territory, substantial military capabilities, vast hydrocarbon reserves, mineral deposits, agricultural resources and a geographical position connecting Europe with Asia. Its oil, natural gas, coal, precious metals, rare-earth potential and strategic transportation corridors represented extraordinary economic and geopolitical assets. For European strategists, a weakened Russia promised a more favorable balance of power, reduced resistance to Western influence and potentially greater leverage over these resources.
The subsequent enlargement of NATO and the European Union steadily shifted Europe’s political and security architecture eastward. Poland, Hungary and the Czech Republic entered NATO in 1999. Bulgaria, Romania, Slovakia and the Baltic states followed in 2004, alongside other countries. Several former Soviet-aligned states also joined the European Union. Western governments presented this expansion as the sovereign choice of countries seeking security and prosperity. Moscow increasingly interpreted the same process as strategic encirclement, the erosion of its regional influence and the gradual construction of a hostile military perimeter.
Ukraine eventually became the most consequential arena of this confrontation. Its geographical position, agricultural wealth, industrial infrastructure, Black Sea access and historical connections with Russia made it strategically indispensable. A Ukraine firmly integrated into Western military structures would fundamentally alter Russia’s security environment. From Moscow’s perspective, the possibility of NATO extending its influence across Ukraine represented a direct challenge to its strategic depth and regional security.
The political upheaval of 2014 intensified these tensions. The overthrow of President Viktor Yanukovych, following mass protests and political confrontation, was celebrated in Western capitals as a democratic breakthrough. Russia characterized the change as a Western-supported coup. Western political involvement and support for Ukraine’s subsequent governments reinforced Moscow’s suspicions. Volodymyr Zelenskyy’s election in 2019, however, occurred through a competitive presidential vote, rather than the 2014 uprising. Nevertheless, Ukraine increasingly became the principal battlefield of competing Russian and Western strategic ambitions.
When Russia launched its full-scale invasion in February 2022, Europe and the United States mobilized enormous financial, military, diplomatic and economic resources behind Ukraine. Sanctions targeted Russian banks, energy exports, technology access and international financial transactions. Western governments expected sustained economic pressure, combined with Ukrainian military resistance, to weaken Moscow’s ability to continue the war. Some anticipated that economic isolation would eventually undermine Russia’s domestic stability and geopolitical influence.
Instead, Russia demonstrated greater economic resilience than many Western policymakers anticipated. Moscow redirected substantial energy exports toward Asian markets, strengthened commercial relationships with China and India, expanded domestic military production and adapted parts of its financial system to sanctions. China became particularly important as a commercial partner and geopolitical counterweight to Western pressure. Although Russia suffered significant military losses, economic disruption and long-term technological constraints, the anticipated rapid collapse of its economy did not materialize.
Europe, meanwhile, discovered that economic warfare could inflict serious costs upon those deploying it. The reduction of Russian energy supplies forced European industries and households to adjust to a fundamentally altered energy market. Germany’s energy-intensive industrial sector faced particularly severe pressures. Higher energy costs, inflation, expensive defense commitments and uncertainty over industrial competitiveness exposed vulnerabilities within economies accustomed to relatively affordable energy and stable international trade.
The political consequences extended beyond economic statistics. Farmers, industrial workers, transport operators and ordinary households across European countries expressed frustration over living costs, declining purchasing power and government priorities. Demonstrations reflected numerous domestic grievances, but energy insecurity and economic pressures associated with the confrontation with Russia intensified an already difficult environment. Resources committed to military expenditure and foreign strategic objectives increasingly competed with demands for better public services, employment security and affordable living conditions.
Donald Trump’s approach to Ukraine further complicated Europe’s calculations. His insistence that European governments assume greater responsibility for their own security exposed the continent’s longstanding dependence upon American military power. Washington’s shifting commitment created uncertainty over the durability of Western support for Kyiv. Europe found itself confronting the possibility of sustaining an expensive confrontation with Russia without the same degree of dependable American leadership and assistance.
The irony is striking. European powers that once dictated the destinies of distant nations now struggle to control the consequences of their own geopolitical ambitions. A strategy intended to isolate Russia has encouraged Moscow to deepen relationships outside the Western economic system. The emergence of BRICS and the growing influence of China illustrate a broader international movement toward alternative commercial and diplomatic arrangements. The Western monopoly over global economic decision-making is increasingly contested.
Russia has not emerged unscathed, nor has Europe alone determined the course of the conflict. Nevertheless, the confrontation demonstrates the limitations of attempting to impose geopolitical outcomes through military alliances, economic coercion and strategic pressure. The belief that a major nuclear power possessing vast resources, territorial depth and powerful international partnerships could be economically strangled into submission has proved dangerously simplistic.
The lesson extends far beyond Russia and Ukraine. Britain, Europe and the United States must confront the declining effectiveness of imperial habits in a world where formerly subordinated nations possess growing economic, technological and diplomatic influence. Threatening territories, expanding military commitments and attempting to police the international system cannot indefinitely substitute for domestic prosperity and political legitimacy.
The time has arrived for Western governments to abandon the illusion that global supremacy guarantees national well-being. Their foremost responsibility is not to control Russia’s resources, redraw geopolitical boundaries or perpetuate confrontations across continents. It is to improve the lives of their own citizens through affordable energy, productive industries, quality healthcare, education, housing and economic security. Europe attempted to weaken Russia through a geopolitical chess game, only to discover that the board could turn against its own players. The greatest victory now available to Europe and America is not the subjugation of another nation, but the restoration of prosperity, stability and dignity to their own people.

Continue Reading

World News

Jewish Religious Extremism: When Faith Defies Strategic Alliances

Published

on

By

Paris (Imran Y. CHOUDHRY) :- Former Press Secretary to the President, Former Press Minister to the Embassy of Pakistan to France, Former MD, SRBC Mr. Qamar Bashir analysis : Strategic alliances rest on an expectation of reciprocity: friendship should command respect, cooperation should earn trust, and support should carry political value. Rabbi Yosef Mizrachi’sRabbi Yosef (Yossi) Mizrachi, an Israeli-American ultra-Orthodox preacher and founder of Divine Information, has spent three decades promoting Torah observance through lectures and digital outreach. Born in Israel in 1968, he served in the Israeli Air Force and worked in Manhattan finance before turning to religious outreach in 1994.
His pronouncements confront strategic alliances with a theological challenge: India’s friendship with Israel counts for less than its religious practices, while Pakistan’s hostility becomes secondary to Muslim monotheism. His argument places religious judgment above national advantage, raising consequential questions for Israel’s partners.
His message exposes a fundamental tension between the pursuit of national advantage and a religious doctrine that ranks nations by their worship. For Israel’s partners, the implications deserve examination beyond the controversy surrounding a sermon.
Mizrachi begins by acknowledging the strength of India’s relationship with Israel. He describes cooperation encompassing weapons, cybersecurity, agriculture, medicine and science, portraying India as perhaps Israel’s closest friend, even ahead of the United States. His account stresses mutual benefit, commercial exchange and goodwill. This recognition is essential to his argument: he understands the strategic value of the partnership before declaring that religious considerations must override it.
His description of Pakistan establishes the opposite pole. He portrays it as an adversary sympathetic to Israel’s opponents and hostile to Jewish security. Yet he then asks his audience which country deserves its sympathy in a conflict. The question places political loyalty and religious classification in direct competition. Friendship, in his reasoning, cannot settle the matter because the decisive criterion lies elsewhere: whether a population worships the God he recognises.
The answer reverses the apparent logic of the comparison. Mizrachi categorises Hindu worship as idolatry and argues that it constitutes a greater offence against God than hostility towards Jews that has not resulted in an attack.
Pakistan consequently receives theological preference because of its Muslim identity. He admits that personal calculation would favour India, but insists that divine judgment requires another standard. Religious obligation, as he interprets it, supersedes strategic gratitude.
This distinction carries implications extending beyond India and Pakistan. It establishes a framework in which an accommodating ally may remain religiously unacceptable while an antagonistic neighbour occupies a superior theological position.
Conduct towards Israel becomes subordinate to belief. The argument also provides a justification for disregarding established partnerships: if cooperation with one country becomes religiously objectionable, God will supposedly provide another source of benefit. Dependence is answered with an assurance of divine substitution.
For New Delhi, this is a challenge to assumptions about the durability of friendship. Commercial cooperation and security coordination may generate mutual interests without removing ideological hostility towards the partner’s faith.
Mizrachi’s argument makes that separation explicit. India is valuable for what it provides, yet its predominantly Hindu identity becomes grounds for condemnation. The resulting question is whether strategic usefulness offers sufficient protection when religious judgment is presented as a higher authority.
Pakistan faces a different calculation. The preference expressed for it arises from monotheism rather than endorsement of its policies or recognition of its grievances. Nevertheless, the argument disrupts the familiar division between friend and enemy. It introduces a religious basis for sympathy across an otherwise adversarial relationship. For Pakistani analysts, the significance lies in examining that contradiction and its possible influence, rather than assuming that theological preference automatically produces diplomatic recognition or practical support.
Mizrachi’s treatment of Christianity reveals a similar collision between dependence and disdain. He acknowledges Christian assistance to Israel while ridiculing Christian beliefs concerning Jesus, sacrifice and salvation. Benefactors are recognised for their contributions even as their faith is subjected to contempt. The contradiction is particularly consequential for supporters whose commitment to Israel is itself religiously motivated. Their devotion becomes useful as a source of support but objectionable as a form of worship.
His remarks about churches take the argument beyond theological disagreement. By describing them as sites of idolatry and invoking the destruction of idols in the land of Israel, he raises questions about the place of Christian worship within his religious vision. The issue concerns the security of sacred spaces and the conditions under which communities can practise their faith. A doctrine that treats another community’s worship as an offence creates tension with religious coexistence.
The discussion of punishment intensifies these concerns. Mizrachi presents idolatry as an offence exceeding murder, theft and rape in severity, then describes execution by stoning or sword.
Elsewhere, his language of vengeance extends destruction to children. These statements establish a hierarchy in which religious transgression can outweigh violence against human beings. Their significance lies in the moral reasoning they communicate: identity and worship become grounds for judgments detached from an individual’s conduct towards others.
His condemnation of expressions of empathy towards gay people follows the same pattern. Compassion itself becomes punishable when directed towards those he condemns. Across these passages, the central demand is obedience to a religious classification that overrides ordinary considerations of reciprocity, sympathy and individual dignity.
The consequences are therefore social as well as diplomatic. Such reasoning influences how audiences understand neighbours, minorities, allies and adversaries, assigning moral status before examining particular actions.
The geopolitical question is how such ideas interact with political power. A sermon can articulate a standard by which supporters subsequently judge leaders, agreements and compromises.
If religious conformity becomes the measure of legitimate partnership, diplomatic flexibility may be denounced as disobedience. Existing alliances can then face pressure from constituencies that regard strategic calculation as an inadequate justification for cooperation. Assessing that possibility requires attention to audiences, institutional connections and the reception of these arguments.
A second interpretation concerns bargaining. Rhetoric that diminishes the value of established allies can communicate that their support should never be taken as decisive. Yet identifying a deliberate pressure campaign requires evidence connecting the language to political actors and specific objectives. The distinction matters because theological conviction and strategic signalling can produce similar words while serving different purposes. The proper inquiry is into their relationship, including whether decisionmakers adopt, amplify or act upon the reasoning.
For Washington and New Delhi, the practical response begins with examining the ideological assumptions accompanying their partnerships. For Pakistan and other Muslim states, it begins with distinguishing religious affinity from dependable political commitments.
Across these relationships, the same question persists: what happens to negotiated interests when an asserted divine obligation demands their abandonment? Mizrachi’s remarks give that question a concrete form, placing the friend who worships differently below the adversary who professes one God.
The significance of this discourse lies in its proposed ordering of international relationships. Gratitude, shared interests and cooperation are made conditional upon religious judgment.
An ally can be praised as indispensable and condemned as spiritually criminal within the same argument. That contradiction warrants sustained scrutiny wherever religious authority intersects with political ambition. Alliances become vulnerable when the value of friendship is acknowledged, then dismissed because the friend prays differently.

Continue Reading

Trending